The Karnataka High Court has quashed criminal proceedings lodged against Hindustan Unilever CEO and managing director Rohit Jawa after a biscuit sample was allegedly found to contain pesticide. The order, passed on July 3 by a bench consisting of Justice J M Khazi, was made publicly available recently.
The court said, “…in the present case, the company is not arraigned as an accused, and therefore the petitioner, who is the sole accused, cannot be proceeded against.” It, however, stated that a fresh complaint could be filed by implicating the company too, as the initial complaint did not name it.
The grievance in this regard was filed by a food safety officer in 2023, under provisions of the Food and Safety Standards Act, based on the discovery that a sample of Horlicks biscuits from a supermarket in Bengaluru contained the pesticide Chlorpyrifos beyond the safe limits. In India, Horlicks is owned by Unilever.
Jawa’s counsel argued that the tests prescribed under the Food Safety and Standards (Contaminants, Toxins and Residues) Regulations were not applicable to finished products such as biscuits. It was also pointed out that the company (Hindustan Unilever) was not named in the case, and as per the law, the CEO was not the manufacturer. Hence, the trial judge should not have taken cognizance of the matter.
On the other hand, the opposing government counsel argued that the MD was responsible for the company’s business. He added that in the event that the proceedings are quashed because the company was not named as an accused in the complaint, liberty ought to be granted to file a fresh petition and implead the company.
Allowing the petitioner to do so, the high court subsequently stated, “…the criminal proceedings against the accused are liable to be quashed…the complainant is at liberty to file a fresh complaint by implicating the company also, and thereafter proceed further.”